Annie Proulx. Brokeback Mountain (1998) Reprint of a New Yorker story. I read about 1/3rd of it and skimmed the rest. The style seems more important than the story, which delineates a homosexual affair between two drifters, both of whom end up loners, losing whatever connection to community they had when they abandon their wives (or vice versa). Raymond Carver I think does a better job of treating such themes. It may be that Proulx intends the story to show that unacknowledged homosexuality exacts a heavy price, but that’s a truism. It may be she wants to show that even among the ill-educated passion flows true and deep, and love hurts. Many New Yorker stories give me the impression, as this one does, that the reader is slumming, perhaps because they are set amidst ads for goods that the characters in the stories will never be able to afford (and may never desire) * (2004)
Update: in 2005, a movie of the story was released, It won 3 Oscars.
Mostly book reviews, plus whatever else I feel like posting. I welcome comments and conversation. Comments are moderated, so it may take a day or two for your comment to appear. Or send a mail to wolfmac@sympatico.ca If you quote, please also link to this blog. If you like this blog, please follow it. Highest review rating is four stars ****
04 May 2013
Annie Proulx. Brokeback Mountain (1998)
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Lapham's Quarterly: Crimes and Punishments (Spring 2009)
Lapham’s Quarterly II/2, Spring 2009. Crimes and Punishments . A difficult read, consisting almost entirely of firsthand accounts. Two crim...
-
Josephine Tey Miss Pym Disposes (1947) Miss Lucy Pym, suddenly famous for her book on psychology, has been invited to her friend Henr...
-
John Cunningham. The Tin Star (Collier’s, December 4, 1947) The short story adapted for High Noon . As often happens, the movie retains v...
-
Today we remember those whom we sent into war on our behalf, and who gave everything they had. They gave their lives. I want to think a...
No comments:
Post a Comment